What Is a Good Return on Equity for a Rental?

What is a good return on equity for a rental? It is a yield that still makes sense compared with what that equity could earn somewhere else you would actually buy, after you have used an honest cash-flow number. Return on equity divides cash left after debt service by the equity trapped in the property today. Equity is current value minus the debt payoff. The ratio does not know your taxes, your selling costs, or whether a different loan exists. It tells you how hard the equity is working. A “good” result is one that beats your real alternatives. A universal percentage does not exist.

Illustrations here are not a rate quote and not an offer of credit. An inquiry is not an approval.

What Is a Good Return on Equity for a Rental You Already Own

Owners meet this ratio years after the purchase, when the original down payment is no longer the right denominator. You might have written a check for $80,000. The house might be worth $400,000 now, with $150,000 of debt left. Equity is $250,000 if you ignore selling costs. Cash left after debt service might be $8,000 a year. Return on equity is $8,000 divided by $250,000, or 3.2 percent.

Cash-on-cash on the old check is a different ratio. The same $8,000 divided by $80,000 is 10 percent. Both numbers are arithmetic. They answer different questions. Cash-on-cash remembers what you invested at closing. Return on equity asks what today’s pile of equity earns if you keep it parked in this building. Cap rate versus cash-on-cash is the purchase-day pair. Return on equity is the hold-day question, and it rises in importance as paydown and appreciation pile value into the house faster than the rent grows.

Here is the same illustration in a table.

Item	Amount
Current value	$400,000
Debt payoff	$150,000
Equity before selling costs	$250,000
Annual cash left after debt service	$8,000
Return on equity	3.2 percent
Same cash flow on the original $80,000	10 percent

The 3.2 percent is not a verdict to sell, and it is not a verdict to refinance. Those decisions have costs this ratio ignores. A sale would net less than $250,000 after commissions and fix-up. A new loan would have its own payment, which would change the $8,000. Measure the yield first. Decide what to do with it only after those costs are on a separate page. This article stops at the yield.

Selling costs belong in the denominator if you want equity you could actually touch. If it would cost $24,000 to sell, touchable equity is $226,000, and $8,000 on $226,000 is about 3.5 percent. Using the gross equity understates the yield slightly and overstates how much money a sale frees. Pick one denominator and label it. Do not compare your gross-equity yield with someone else’s after-cost yield and call the gap a strategy.

Use Cash Flow You Would Actually Keep

The numerator is cash left after debt service, built the way rental cash flow builds it. Collected rent, minus vacancy you believe, minus tax, insurance, repairs, management, and a reserve, minus the full principal-and-interest payment. If you leave the reserve out, the return on equity looks higher and the roof is unfunded. A “good” return that spends every dollar is a thin reserve policy, not a high yield.

Debt changes the numerator and the denominator in opposite directions. Borrowing less leaves more cash flow and less equity only if you put the extra cash in at the start. On a house you already own, a low loan balance means the denominator is large. The payment is small, so most of the operating result falls to equity, and the yield on that large equity drifts toward the unlevered yield of the building. Negative leverage is the related case at purchase: when the debt costs more than the asset yields, borrowing can pull the equity yield below the cap rate. On a nearly free-and-clear rental, you are not in that purchase math anymore. You are earning something close to the cap rate on a lot of equity, minus the capital items you forgot. That can be a fine outcome. It can also be a sleepy one. The ratio is how you notice.

Whether to pay off the rental or keep the mortgage changes both sides of the fraction. Paying the loan off eliminates the payment and increases equity by the payoff amount. Run the ratio both ways before you wire the payoff. Sometimes the cash flow rises by less than the equity rises, and the return on equity falls. That is not automatically the wrong move. It is a move you should see in the fraction rather than feel in the relief of having no payment.

Do not drop in a national rent figure as the numerator’s starting point. The rent is this lease, checked against nearby leases. A return on equity built from a metro average describes a metro, not your house.

Good Compared With What

Compare 3.2 percent with the yield on the next property you would actually buy with the equity you could free, and with the yield on doing nothing. The next property’s yield is a cash-on-cash figure on the cash you would invest there, which is not the same ratio, so write both labels down. If the alternative is another rental at 4 percent cash-on-cash after reserves, and getting there costs a sale and a purchase, 3.2 percent on the house you know may be the better risk. If the alternative is clearly stronger and you can reach it, the trapped equity is expensive. “Good” is that comparison. It is not a blog’s threshold.

A cap rate is the unlevered cousin. Net operating income divided by value ignores the loan. Return on equity uses cash after the loan and divides by equity, not by value. On a free-and-clear building they converge, once you define operating income and cash flow the same way. On a leveraged building they should not match. Quoting a cap rate as if it were your return on equity double-counts the concept and hides the payment.

Tax sits outside the 3.2 percent. IRS Topic 414 treats rent as taxable rental income and allows rental expenses, including depreciation, which is not a cash outlay. The cash yield above is pre-tax. Your after-tax cash depends on the rest of your return. This page does not state a tax rate, because Topic 414 does not give you one number to subtract from every landlord. If you want an after-tax return on equity, compute the tax on this property and subtract it from the $8,000 before you divide. Label the result after-tax so you do not compare it with someone else’s pre-tax 3.2 percent.

Appreciation is not inside the ratio. Return on equity, as used here, is a cash yield on trapped equity. A house that cash-flows at 3.2 percent and also appreciates may be a better hold than the cash ratio shows. Put appreciation in a separate line and admit you do not know it. Folding a hoped-for resale into “return on equity” is how a weak cash yield gets a new name. If appreciation is the reason you keep a low cash yield, say that in the same note as the 3.2 percent.

Illustrative ranges help only as a way to read your own number. A return on equity under the yield you can get on a plain alternative, with no appreciation you are willing to underwrite, is weak. A return on equity that matches a careful cash-on-cash target on your next purchase is doing the job. A very high return on equity sometimes means the value is stale and too low, or the cash flow omitted a reserve, or the debt is large and the equity is small. Check the inputs before you congratulate the ratio. Small equity makes any cash flow look like a huge percentage, and it also means a vacancy wipes out the equity cushion in the coverage sense. High yield and high fragility travel together when the denominator is thin.

Ready to discuss business-purpose financing options for an investment property? Call (907) 841-1600 or use the contact form.

Start an Inquiry →

Frequently Asked Questions

How do I calculate return on equity on a rental I already own?

Divide annual cash left after debt service by today’s equity, which is current value minus the loan payoff. What is a good return on equity for a rental depends on that pair, not on the down payment from the year you bought. Subtract selling costs first if you want equity a sale would actually free. Use a numerator that already includes a reserve you would fund.

Why is my cash-on-cash return much higher than my return on equity?

The denominators diverged. Cash-on-cash divides by the cash you originally invested, while return on equity divides by the equity in the property now, which grew if the value rose or the loan paid down. An $8,000 cash flow can be 10 percent of an $80,000 down payment and about 3 percent of a much larger current equity. Both can be true in the same year.

Does a low return on equity mean I should sell or refinance?

The ratio does not say that. It says the equity is earning the yield you just calculated, and selling costs, the next property, and a new payment are separate math. Run those before you treat a low percentage as an instruction. A low yield is a reason to do that next page of work, not a closing date.

Should I include appreciation in return on equity?

Not in the cash version of the ratio. Appreciation is uncertain and it is not cash left after debt service. Track it on its own line. If the only reason the hold looks attractive is a resale gain, the cash return on equity is telling you the truth about current cash, and the bet is the resale.

Is return on equity the same as the cap rate?

No. A cap rate divides operating income before debt service by the property value, while return on equity divides cash after the full payment by equity. They land near each other when the property is almost free and clear and you defined income the same way. With a meaningful loan, they measure different slices.