What Is a Good Equity Multiple

What is a good equity multiple in real estate? Divide all the cash the property returned to you by all the cash you invested. The quotient is the multiple. A result of 1.0 means you got your cash back and nothing more. A result above 1.0 means more cash came back than went in. “Good” depends on how long the money was out and what else you could have done with it. The multiple itself has no clock. It does not know whether the cash returned in four years or in fourteen.

These figures are an illustration. They are not a rate quote, an offer of credit, or a prediction of profit. An inquiry is not an approval.

What Is a Good Equity Multiple in Real Estate

Total cash returned, divided by total cash invested, equals the equity multiple.

Cash invested is the cash you put into the deal and do not get back as a loan. The down payment counts. Closing costs you pay in cash count. Capital you add later for a roof or a turnover counts, if that cash came from you and not from a new loan or from property income you had already counted as a distribution. The loan principal does not count as cash invested. The lender’s dollars are not your dollars.

Cash returned is every dollar the project sends you. Annual cash flow after debt service counts. Cash from a refinance that you take out of the property counts. Cash from the sale, after selling costs and after the loan payoff, counts. The original cash is inside that total. The multiple includes the return of your investment, not only the profit on top.

Here is a hold:

• Cash invested at purchase: $100,000
• Cash flow after debt service: $5,000 a year for six years, or $30,000
• Sale: contract price $400,000, selling costs $24,000, loan payoff $220,000
• Cash from the sale: $156,000
• Total cash returned: $186,000
• Equity multiple: 1.86

You received $1.86 for each $1.00 you invested. One dollar of that is your own cash coming home. The other $0.86 is the surplus. An annual yield would divide a result by time. This multiple leaves the six years out of the math.

Cash out	Amount
Down payment and cash closing costs	$100,000
Cash back
Six years of cash flow	$30,000
Sale proceeds after costs and payoff	$156,000
Total cash returned	$186,000
Equity multiple	1.86

Change only the sale check. If the sale returns $70,000, total cash returned is $100,000 and the multiple is 1.00. You were made whole. The six years your $100,000 was tied up never enter the 1.00. A multiple can look complete while the wait was long.

Why the Multiple Ignores Time

Two properties can both show 1.86. One returned the cash in a short hold. One took more than twice as long. The equity multiple scores them the same. You should not. A faster return of the same dollars is more useful, because you can put the cash into the next property sooner, and because less can go wrong while you wait. The multiple will not award that speed. You have to award it yourself by refusing to compare multiples across wildly different holds without writing the time down beside them.

What is a good IRR for real estate puts a clock on the same cash flows. IRR cares whether the $5,000 arrived each year or all at the end, and it cares how long until the sale. A high equity multiple with a distant sale can be a modest IRR. A modest multiple with a quick sale can be a strong IRR. Use the multiple to see how many dollars came back. Use IRR when the calendar is the question. They answer different questions, so they are allowed to disagree.

What is a good cash-on-cash return is a single period. Five thousand dollars of cash flow divided by $100,000 invested is 5 percent for that year. Cash-on-cash ignores the sale and ignores the other years. The equity multiple adds every year and the sale, then refuses to divide by time. You can have a 5 percent cash-on-cash and a disappointing multiple if the sale check is thin. You can have a weak cash-on-cash and a strong multiple if the sale does the heavy lifting. Read both before you call the hold a success.

The SEC’s Office of Investor Education and Advocacy explains, in its investor bulletin on performance claims, that performance can be presented in many ways and that past performance does not necessarily predict future results. The bulletin tells you to see how a number is calculated, including which fees are inside it. Equity multiple is one of those numbers. A sponsor’s 1.86 that ignores fees you paid, or that uses a sale price nobody has offered, is a different 1.86 from the one you compute off your own bank account.

What to Include So the Multiple Stays Honest

Fees and selling costs reduce cash returned. If you leave the $24,000 commission out of the sale math, the sale check becomes $180,000, total cash returned becomes $210,000, and the multiple becomes 2.10. You did not receive the extra $24,000. Put actual costs in. The bulletin’s point about fees applies here even though the bulletin is written for investment performance in general.

A refinance distribution counts when it reaches you. Suppose in year four you take $40,000 of cash-out proceeds and you do not reinvest them in the building. Add $40,000 to cash returned. The loan payoff at the eventual sale will be higher because you borrowed more, so the sale check shrinks. Count both effects. Counting the cash-out and forgetting the fatter payoff inflates the multiple. Leaving the cash-out out, while still using the fatter payoff, deflates it.

Cash you pull from property income and immediately spend on a capital project never became a distribution. Do not add it to cash returned and also add it to cash invested. If you fund the roof from a new check you write, add the check to cash invested. If you fund it from cash flow you would otherwise have distributed, you simply have less cash flow in the “returned” column. Pick the path that matches the bank account.

Reserves you never get back belong in cash invested, or they reduce cash returned. A $100,000 figure that ignores $8,000 of closing cash and $6,000 of capital spent in year two understates the denominator. The multiple rises on paper. Your wallet does not match it.

Taxes are personal. This illustration is pre-tax. If you need the multiple after tax, subtract the tax you attribute to the rental and to the sale from cash returned, or treat the tax checks as cash that left. Do not compare your after-tax multiple with someone else’s pre-tax multiple. Capital gains tax on rental property measures the federal tax on the gain. The multiple stays a cash figure. A large taxable gain can sit next to a modest equity multiple if you had little cash in the deal, and a small taxable gain can sit next to a weak multiple if the sale barely returned your capital.

When a Multiple Is Good Enough to Matter

Above 1.0, you received more cash than you put in. That is the first gate, and it is a low one. A 1.10 multiple after a long hold can lose to a simpler alternative. A 1.80 multiple on a short hold, with documented rents and a sale price already in a contract, is a different fact. Write the hold length beside the multiple, and note fees, reserves, capital calls, and taxes you left out. If a pro forma sale is doing the work, keep in-place cash flow in its own column until the sale is real. On a partnership, use your cash in and your cash out.

Ready to discuss business-purpose financing options for an investment property? Call (907) 841-1600 or use the contact form.

Start an Inquiry →

Frequently Asked Questions

Does the equity multiple include the return of my original investment?

Yes. Total cash returned includes your capital coming back plus anything above it. A multiple of 1.0 is a return of capital with no surplus. A multiple of 2.0 means two dollars came back per dollar in, and one of those dollars is the dollar you started with. Quoting only the surplus as the multiple will make every deal look worse than the standard definition, or better, depending on which way the error runs. Use the gross cash back in the numerator.

Is a higher equity multiple always better?

A higher multiple means more cash came back per dollar invested. It is better when the time, the risk, and the fees are comparable. A higher multiple that takes far longer can be worse for you than a lower multiple that returns capital quickly. The ratio will not show the difference. Write the hold length beside it.

How is equity multiple different from cash-on-cash return?

Cash-on-cash divides one period of cash flow by the cash you invested. It ignores the sale and the other periods. Equity multiple adds every distribution and the sale proceeds, then divides by cash invested, with no adjustment for when the cash arrived. A strong cash-on-cash year can still produce a weak multiple if the sale is poor.

Should refinance cash-out count as cash returned?

Count it when you take the cash out of the property. Then count the higher loan payoff at the sale, because that payoff reduces the sale check. Skipping either side biases the multiple. Cash-out proceeds you spend on a capital improvement at the property are not a distribution. They stayed in the deal.

Can two partners have different equity multiples on one property?

Yes. The project can return one pool of cash while the agreement sends different shares to different partners, or while one partner invested earlier. Compute cash returned to you divided by cash invested by you. Your own cash in and cash out is the ratio that matches your account.